I first had the opportunity to play Firefall at PAX East in 2011. Even in those early stages, with the focus being primarily on arena style PvP , the beauty of the game was immediately gripping. In the time since, both the focus and the aesthetic of Red 5's sci-fi 3rd person MMO have evolved and been honed. Sadly, not all has been for the better.
The first thing anyone notices when playing Firefall is the vibrant colour palette and refined cell-shaded texturing and line work that are used to accent an already wonderfully crafted world. Unfortunately, if you play with the frankly gorgeous HD textures enabled, they're streamed to your computer in real-time, causing strange texture swapping effects, and once streamed, they stick around in the AppData folder, with no official support to relocate them. If you're like me and keep a minimal OS partition, or use a small SSD for your OS, this can easily use an unacceptable amount of hard drive space in an area where it can't be spared. While it is possible to change the texture folder to a different location, it requires the editing of a game file that's inconveniently blank if you play the game on Steam. If you opt to remedy this issue by simply playing with the lower resolution textures, the game still offers up the same wonderful colours, but fails to impress with its lack of detail. Red 5 cite the problem of doubling the install size as their reason for streaming the textures, but don't address why they're not stored in the game's install directory, nor do the elaborate on why 20 or so GB would be so unacceptable when newer titles are starting to double even that.
Surprisingly for a game with so many classes on offer, they are all varied and interesting enough to be justified, each having their own selection of core abilities and signature weapons. Unfortunately, for all but the Recon types with their powerful rifles and the Engineer types with their supporting turrets, the different primary weapons suffer such extreme drawbacks that it's almost always preferable to use the game's secondary weapons with their significant damage, accuracy and infinite ammo instead. This is a saddening realization to come to, as the signature weapons of the different Frames are quite satisfying to use. Shame, then, that most of them are hopelessly impractical for use against most of the PvE enemies in the game, and the PvP for which they were balanced is no longer present.
Even the game's resource gathering for its rather two-dimensional crafting system is nothing more than holdout missions on mineral veins sussed out with a giant hammer. To top it all off, Firefall's point of pride, it's competitive PvP was removed for reworking just before launch, leaving players with only a poorly tacked on PvE aspect to occupy them until it returns at an unknown date. All of this is in tragic contrast to the game's earlier iterations which, while not having the most intense PvP, at least had fantastic balancing methods for character loadouts that forced players to choose their strengths and weaknesses within a series of constraints, rather than the current model of newer and higher level is always better. The sad truth is that in listening to the demands of everyone in their community, rather than just those who understood their vision, Red 5 have diluted a beautiful world with excellent potential into a muddled mess of a game without its flagship PvP and little to justify the headache of managing those wonderful textures, even at the free-to-play price point.
For all the mess that it is, I actually like Firefall, and truly hope the game can be redeemed. Everyone has a guilty pleasure game that they are embarrassed to be caught playing. One that they stick with in the hopes that the developer may one day come upon the right formula to shape it into the game it deserves to be. For me, that game is Firefall. By nearly every measure, there's nothing Firefall does that some other title doesn't do much better, but I keep looking optimistically towards the future. Sadly, the type of major system reworks the game would need are almost never seen post-launch. That being said, Red 5 is already attempting just that with their PvP reimagining, so there may be hope yet. For the time being though,