Opens in a new tab

Warhammer Survivors (PS5) Review

Warhammer Survivors (PS5) Review

None Will Survive!

Warhammer Survivors (PS5) Review
Warhammer Survivors Warhammer Survivors (PS5) Review
CGM Review Template - V15

I know I say this a lot, but Warhammer Survivors genuinely did catch me by surprise. Warhammer has been pretty comfortably doing its own thing with solid action games for the past few years, so it really seemed like it found a distinct video game identity. At the same time, the success of Vampire Survivors did see a lot of third-party studios trying to replicate both its gameplay and earnings; I figured enough time had passed that people had moved on from that particular bandwagon. 

Warhammer Survivors (PS5) Review

I’ve said before that imitation is the most sincere form of flattery, but I’ve also stressed that creators need to both understand their inspiration and evolve it in some way. To that point, Warhammer Survivors left me a bit disappointed. Its heart is certainly in the right place, but it fundamentally doesn’t seem to understand the game it’s replicating, creating an experience that feels unbalanced and generally unfun. 

There really isn’t a lot to say about Warhammer Survivors, because it’s pretty openly replicating Vampire Survivors. From its look to its gameplay, the way enemies spawn, even the way chests open, it’s Poncel’s game almost all the way down—sans Poncel’s direct involvement. And, to its credit, it mostly works. Vampire Survivors is such a great game that even a naked copy of it is going to be enjoyable to some degree. It’s even got a few unique touches that I actually really like.

“There really isn’t a lot to say about Warhammer Survivors, because it’s pretty openly replicating Vampire Survivors.”

Fundamentally, Tyranids make an excellent enemy for a bullet heaven since, within the Warhammer mythos, they attack in massive swarms. Not only that, but the soundtrack is particularly great—utilizing a mix of operatic, almost hymnal themes with hard metal that defines Warhammer. And I like how the game leans into its tabletop inspirations, providing players with upgrades like explosive dice, modelling glue and miniature paint. However, much like the mini-figures themselves, the devil is in the details, and this is where Warhammer Survivors does falter somewhat. 

Warhammer Survivors (PS5) Review

The game’s biggest issue is its balancing. As you progress through each level, XP is dropped at such a pathetic rate that it starts taking forever to level up and gain the necessary upgrades to deal with the increasing difficulty. Not only that, but the attacks and upgrades that you begin with are kind of worthless and make unlocking subsequent better abilities a genuine chore.

I know Vampire Survivors did a similar thing, but it at least gave you a wider variety of choices based on what character you were using to make each run interesting. Here, because none of the characters are particularly distinct—due in large part to Warhammer lore—practically everyone basically gets a Boltgun and a Chainsword, and it takes hours of fairly monotonous gameplay to get anything useful. Once you do, it is fun to see how many Warhammer-themed weapons found their Vampire Survivors-styled equivalents.

It’s just a shame because, for a game that is so openly copying Vampire Survivors, if they had sought Poncel’s involvement, I have no doubt this could’ve been an incredible Warhammer-styled homage to the game that cemented the bullet heaven genre. Instead, it just kind of feels like a pale imitation—I genuinely didn’t think I could get bored with Vampire Survivors, but here we are. Even its meta-progression is bland, locking new levels behind reaching certain levels or surviving long enough, instead of exploring each level and finding the key items that unlock the next. 

Warhammer Survivors (PS5) Review

However, as I mentioned above, Warhammer Survivors is kind of like pizza—even when it’s bad, it’s still pizza. I’m not sure why this wasn’t just DLC for Vampire Survivors, similar to the Ode to Castlevania expansion. However, the fundamentals of Poncel’s incredible game are essentially intact, so if you’re willing to stick with it through the grind, or love Warhammer enough to want its skin placed over the Vampire Survivors skeleton, you’ll definitely get something out of Warhammer Survivors.

Final Thoughts

REVIEW SCORE
Jordan Biordi
Jordan Biordi
Jordan Biordi is a long-time CGM Author, as well as actual self-trained ninja. When he's not busy combating the forces of evil, he makes videos on the hilariously mediocre Youtube channel: Ninja-Jordan Reviews. As a Ninja, his heightened reflexes, increased intellect, unshakable discipline, and a deeper understanding of the universe makes him the ideal candidate to review video games!

This post may contain affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something, CGMagazine may earn a commission. However, please know this does not impact our reviews or opinions in any way. See our ethics statement and review policy.